AI Policy for Good Attorneys At Law, PA

(1) Privacy, security and confidentiality come first: I am fully aware that open AI models train those models on the data you feed it. I assume so even if they say they don’t. I know that if the price is free (or even sometimes if you pay), you’re the product. As such, I never enter into any open AI model information or documents that contain a client’s name or other identifying information, or sensitive information about their business or other affairs. My prompts are “generalized”, so that they can’t be associated with anyone in particular, or research-oriented, which just asks for law and analysis that’s publicly available.

(2) I do not use AI content as final work product: AI is better each day at producing draft agreements and so forth, but I use the output only as a model, template, or basis for further development. My clients never receive canned content that I have not personally reviewed and edited.

(3) Facts, cases and statutes are always verified: Hallucinations and errors, while WAY less frequent than they used to be, are still a thing. Fortunately, the models have gotten a lot better at footnoting the text with the original sources of the information. I always review any case law, statutes, or articles to see that what was produced in the AI summary is legitimate and correct.

 
(4) AI productivity gains are passed on to you in the bill:  If I am billing you hourly, you will receive the benefit of net productivity gains I receive from AI.  I say “net” because, as I mentioned, I do not regurgitate AI content without oversight.  Also, just knowing what question to ask AI in the first place and how to phrase the prompt definitely relies on my 25+ years of experience, which has value.  As such, AI efficiency gains will be passed along to you, just perhaps not on a 1:1 basis.  What I don’t do is use the big firm “feeding frenzy” billing model, that is, charge you multiple times for multiple people doing arguably the same thing, or stuff your bills full of minimum charges for what things used to cost.